Thanksgiving Trivia:
1) In the movie Holiday Inn (1942) there is an animated sequence in which the turkey logo on the calendar can’t seem to find the right day for thanksgiving (Watch on YouTube!) why is the bird confused? (Hint: it has nothing to do with which week is the last of the month).
2) In Holiday Inn Bing Crosby sings the song “I've got plenty to be thankful for”, what song replaced it in the later film White Christmas (1954) and why?
3) What film made for a summer release (now a Christmas classic) was filmed in New York during the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade and required the cooperation of both Macys and Gimbals department stores?
4) The first president to “pardon” a turkey was Abraham Lincoln, can you name the president who made the presentation of the turkey to the white house an annual tradition, and the president who issued the first Formal Pardon for the turkey?
View our Rumble Video: https://rumble.com/v1vjaig-thanksgiving-2022.html
Main Article:
In November we celebrate Thanksgiving with roasted Turkey (most of us), and added to that are all the traditional favorites; potatoes (both white and sweet), for some the green bean casserole, and cranberry sauce (either from the can or homemade), and every imaginable form of bread. There are family dishes and local dishes, everyone has something nice for their table not found elsewhere. There are European and American dishes and an increasingly vast number of dishes from other cultures and countries as the nation grows. This pales in comparison to the desert table which again is a feast unto itself and contains nearly every form of desert in America, from the venerable Pumpkin Pie to pumpkin spice cream and everything in between.
We celebrate a day of thanksgiving with this vast and often (for most of the year) unimaginable feast a day of thanks, but for what are we thankful?
In our country’s past, the days of thanksgiving had themes. For instance, As far back as 512-530 AD Brendan of Clonfert (called Saint Brendan the Navigator) may have found his way to North America, in the oldest written version of his voyage (written in about 900); there are thanksgiving celebrations in several of the islands they land on. Near the end, Brendan has a vision during one of the thanksgiving observances and returns home. In 1579 British explorer Martin Frobisher led a fleet of fifteen ships in search of the Northwest Passage one of the ships was lost to the ice the fleet was scattered by ice and storms and reunited in what is called Frobisher Bay in the Area of Baffin Island. When the fourteen ships reunited the minister on board led them all ashore to celebrate a day of thanksgiving; they were thankful that the losses were small and their supplies allowed for them to return to England and try again in the next year. Frobisher eventually made three voyages Ito the region.
The famous “first” (it is beyond the scope of this article to debate where and when the first thanksgiving occurred in America, with all due respect to both Massachusetts and Virginia) thanksgiving in Massachusetts was to be thankful for the blessing of having survived long enough to harvest the food. Just a year earlier the entire colony had been rationed to three pieces of vegetable matter which included such delicacies as a single Kernel of Corn one pea and a small (meaning less than the size of your thumb) chunk of bread, this had o be shortened again later to survive the winter.
During the war for American Independence, the Generals and the Congress declared several days of thanksgiving for various disasters averted, victories won, or even for not having lost the war yet.
In 1789 the newly formed constitutional government issued a proclamation calling for a national day of Thanksgiving for the blessings of our freedom (See the Proclamation Here). This practice continued for generations. Among the most famous of these proclamations are Washington's first thanksgiving proclamation, Lincoln’s Thanksgiving proclamations (at least one of which came with the pardon of a turkey), the proclamations for VE (Victory in Europe) Day, and VJ (Victory in Japan) Day.
One of our enduring traditions was started by President Lincoln when his son requested that they not kill the thanksgiving turkey and the president signed a “pardon” for the bird. The practice was not observed by many presidents, in 1947 Harry S Truman made the presentation of the official White House Turkey an annual event. President Ronald Reagan was the first to provide a “Pardon” ceremony for the White House Turkey before sending them to a petting zoo, and President George H.W. Bush made the event an annual tradition beginning in 1989 when he provided a formal pardon to the turkeys.
Another of our unique traditions is the eating of a thanksgiving turkey. The origin of which is said to go back to Benjamin Franklin. Doing the debates on the new symbols for our nation Franklin believed that our national bird and the symbol of the nation should be the turkey. He reasoned that the turkey is: 1) native to America, 2) very brave and would try to chase off an entire regiment single-handedly, and 3) was at times the sole sustenance of the early colonists. Perhaps we eat the turkey at thanksgiving for some of the same reasons.
In all of this discussion of the holiday we may be missing the point; the thanksgiving feast is nice the gatherings are fun, but what are we giving thanks for? For nearly two hundred years the annual celebrations of thanksgiving were not about the food or the gatherings they were about giving thanks. Let us travel back to the 1620s and look at the first thanksgiving situation and see what they were thankful for.
King James refused to allow any other religion in the kingdom and had any practitioner of other faiths arrested, jailed, and tried for sedition. Some of these groups left for more reasonable countries including Holland but found that the prevailing cultures in those lands were not consistent with the way they wished to raise their children. Returning to England they began to petition the King for permission to form a new colony in British North America to worship as they pleased and be out of the King's sight. Their petition was granted they began making preparations to sail including the renting of ships and the purchase of supplies despite setbacks they eventually managed to squeeze all who were going into the hold of one ship the Mayflower, as they prepared some families came whole some left children intending to send for them when the new colony was established. The voyage was fraught with terror storms and damage to the ship, one man fell overboard but was rescued some died on the voyage, and some children were born in the cramped hold. Upon arriving they had been blown off course and landed in what is today New England rather than in the Virginia Colony as planned. They prayed and signed the Mayflower Compact to build a government for their new colony. Over several months they cleared land and attempted to plant seeds and build houses. As winter came on they ran so short of food that each member of the colony was for a time reduced to just a few Kernels of corn; they buried nearly half the colony as people died either of disease or starvation. In the spring they met the local Indian tribes and learned to hunt, fish, and plant in ways that were not common in England. By fall they had more food than they could use. The colonists invited the Indians who had provided aid to join them in a celebration of thanksgiving for the blessings that God had poured out on both people, food, shelter, friendship, and peace were good for all.
So what are we thankful for today, there are many reasons to be upset and bitter but far more reasons to show gratitude. We live in a country where we can speak our minds, associate with the people we choose, and pray (or not ) as we wish. We have guardians in the form of military, police, fire, and rescue personnel who keep us safe so that we can enjoy these things.
In 2020 as the COVID pandemic was causing despair the leader of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints made a video for the entire world about Gratitude one of his quotes perhaps sums up the entire thanksgiving season better than most of us ever will: “Counting our blessings is far better than recounting our problems. No matter our situation, showing gratitude for our privileges is a unique, fast-acting, and long-lasting spiritual prescription.” —President Russell M. Nelson (View Full Video Here)
References:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0034862/?ref_=tttr_tr_tt
Thanksgiving (United States). (2022, October 28). In Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving_(United_States)
Thanksgiving. (2022, October 19). In Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving
Brendan. (2022, September 29). In Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brendan
https://www.loc.gov/resource/mgw8a.124/?q=1789+Thanksgiving&sp=132&st=text
https://www.mass.gov/info-details/bradfords-manuscript-of-plimoth-plantation
https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/2012/11/21/thanksgiving-with-the-presidents/
https://www.whitehousehistory.org/pardoning-the-thanksgiving-turkey