In the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien, Bilbo Baggins (The Hobbit) writes a walking song which is used several times: “The Road goes ever on and on Down from the door where it began. Now far ahead the Road has gone, And I must follow, if I can, Pursuing it with eager feet, Until it joins some larger way Where many paths and errands meet. And whither then? I cannot say.” In some of the other verses Bilbo and his nephew and adopted heir Frodo muse on being able to see their destinations as home, retirement, or the end of their journey even in at least one instance death.
One of the themes of this cycle of poems is looking back to see how far we have come. This is important in all long journeys not just a simple hike or quest but even multi-generational journeys by nations. Looking back into the darkness or challenging slopes can encourage us to move forward. This however raises a question which of these (for individuals and nations) teaches better: the burnt hand or looking back to avoid the pitfalls of those who came before?
If the burnt hand, we need to keep pain, insult, offense, etc., fresh and sharp to keep us on the path; we need to wallow in the mistakes and misery of the past to avoid doing it again. But, if looking back and seeing the progress, improvement, and (incomplete but continuing) success is the best teacher then we need to be able to see the dark mists, caves, cliffs, and other near-disasters that nearly ended the journey, but without having to be made miserable and wallow in them as we now know what to look for to avoid them.
In recent years it has become popular to cancel or erase parts of the past for not living up to our ideals. And yet it was an American slave owner who first opined that slavery degrades not only the slave but the master as well, by creating and reinforcing the idea of a superior and inferior race, creed, etc. Also, it was Americans who propounded the idea that all men are created equal, but, our Founding Fathers were not fools. They realized that it would take generations to undo the damage that slavery had caused; they could not create and maintain a nation without the slaveholders and the slave traders. However, they set the nation on a course that could, as history shows lead to a better nation and a better world. We should not judge them too harshly; they were the best men and minds of their time and did the best they could. In the future history will undoubtedly say of this generation that we were a dark age on some issue that at present seems reasonable. Every generation must be judged by their own time and the understanding they have.
In the past, we made promises knowing that we might not live to see them fulfilled: for instance Jefferson resolved to free his slaves and while unsuccessful began searching for a non-slave option for his plantation. Later he wrote as part of the original draft of the Declaration of Independence that slavery was wrong and that as a new nation, we would abolish it, this passage was removed by congress to get some of the states to support the document.
No less a man than Benjamin Franklin, illustrated the nature and genius of the Constitution when he said: “I confess that I do not entirely approve this Constitution at present; but sir, I am not sure I shall never approve it: For, having lived long, I have experienced many instances of being obliged, by better information or fuller consideration, to change opinions even on important subjects, which I once thought right, but found to be otherwise. It is therefore that, the older I grow, the more apt I am to doubt my own judgment and pay more respect to the judgment of others.”
“In these sentiments, sir, I agree to this Constitution with all its faults—if they are such—because I think a general government necessary for us . . . I doubt, too, whether any other convention we can obtain may be able to make a better Constitution; for, when you assemble a number of men, to have the advantage of their joint wisdom, you inevitably assemble with those men all their prejudices, their passions, their errors of opinion, their local interests, and their selfish views. From such an assembly can a perfect production be expected?
It, therefore, astonishes me, sir, to find this system approaching so near to perfection as it does; and I think it will astonish our enemies, who are waiting with confidence to hear that our councils are confounded like those of the builders of Babel and that our States are on the point of separation, only to meet hereafter for the purpose of cutting one another’s throats. Thus I consent, sir, to this Constitution because I expect no better, and because I am not sure that it is not the best (Excerpted from “Benjamin Franklin” by Walter Isaacson; Apple Books edition).”
Doctor Franklin during his life made several changes in his thinking. In one of his last documents, he proposed a general abolition of slavery including a detailed program for education apprenticeships and even employment agencies for the freed slaves. As part of this plan, he included the idea that schools should be open to all and integrated.
In the preamble to the Constitution, we read that one of the goals of the document is to form a more perfect union; (emphasis added) these words are not a coincidence nor are they meaningless. Our Founders knew that the nation could not be perfected immediately, and they sought rather than a perfect nation, to build one that could and they hoped would grow more perfect each generation.
Less than one hundred years after this passage was written were born some of the greatest writers orators and businessmen in our history; let us consider a few of them and how they were connected, Phineas Taylor Barnum, Samuel Longhorn Clemens (Mark Twain), and Frederick Douglass. Douglass and Barnum were both powerful speakers and lobbied the governments for the end of slavery. Barnum ran for congress and Douglass met with congressmen, and President Lincoln; gave speeches, and published books. Douglass is one of the men who made it possible for free slaves to serve in the army during the civil war. These three men wrote letters and corresponded for much of their lives. Douglass and Barnum were always optimistic about the future of the country and looked back to see where we came from and forward to see where we were going. Clemens was the skeptic of the group he felt that given the opportunity mankind would always do the worst thing. In their correspondence Douglass and Clemens disagree but remain friends; of the two the one with the most reason to be bitter would seem to the former slave; but Douglass is always trying to convince Clemens of the bright future, Clemens is the bitter unhappy man.
One Hundred years after the end of the Civil war the Reverend Martin Luther King called on the United States to live up to our ideals and make good on the promises of the past. He dreamed like Franklin, Douglass, Barnum, and many others of a time when men would be judged by the content of their character and not by the color of their skin (he could also have added: religion, ethnicity, and hundreds of other demographics). We live in a nation where that goal is within reach. It is not perfect but it is getting more perfect. While there is still more work to do if we look back we can see that we have moved closer to these promises and we are not sliding back into the past. In our country at present, while there are still inequalities, we have seen the rise of people from every race and religion to the top in nearly every industry and profession.
In recent years there has been a movement to cancel and erase history. It is done to avoid offense or pain etc. But, it just removes the warning signs and guard rails of the past, making the road ahead far more dangerous. Peter Jackson's movie The Fellowship of The Ring opens with a brief history of the rings of power and contains the following: “Much that once was is lost. For none now live who remember it.” And later: “And Some things that should not have been forgotten were lost. history became legend, legend became myth.” When we allow history to be lost like this, whether by canceling it or just forgetting it, we risk repeating the mistakes of the past and entering a new dark age. So which teaches best the burned hand of repetition, or the study and remembrance of the past no matter how offensive?
As we celebrate the Holiday for Martin Luther King Day let us reflect on the road that goes ever on and as Tolkien in another verse writes: “Now far ahead the Road has gone, Let others follow it who can!” And resolve to look back on what has been accomplished and move forward on the road we all follow to make a more perfect union!